So when populists argue that they offer a return to a purer form of democracy, they are in a sense right. All talk of “rule of law” or “balancing competing interests” is just a smokescreen for not doing what the people demand. They tell the electorate that the only reason governments don’t give them exactly what they want is that the political elites are in cahoots to defend their own interests and those of whom they rely on to maintain power. This is what populist parties-left, right and centre-all promise.

The danger we face today, however, is that some people have lost patience with the rule of law and yearn for a purer form of democracy. This kind of democracy is of course the corner stone of civilised society. They are rather what he called polities: good forms of government in which the many rule over themselves. That means our cherished forms of government are not actually democracies in Aristotle’s sense at all. In the contemporary west the rule of law is a core principle that stands alongside representative government by popular election. What we call modern democracies have traditionally accepted the need for the rule of law to stand between the expression of popular will and its implementation. If the people decide that a person or company’s assets should be seized, again, the fact that this requires tearing up the law book is irrelevant. If the people decide someone should be executed, they are executed and no law against capital punishment can stop that. In a puredemocracy, the will of the majority is sovereign, not the law, not the state. Without this there is nothing to stop those who hold the most power doing what they want and tyrannising everyone else. A functioning state requires that everything is governed by laws. They are more relevant in the age of Trump than ever.Īristotle’s key objection to democracy was that it undermined the rule of law. Aristotle’s criticisms of democracy were often insightful and prescient. But to dismiss all of his arguments completely would be a mistake. It is with good reason that few swallow his prescriptions for a healthy polis wholesale. He even thought a good monarchy was better than a democracy. Aristotle’s favoured form of government was the rule by the best over the rest, an aristocracy based on merit rather than blood. Many would deal with his negative views of democracy in the same way. Plato and Aristotle in Raphael's 1509 fresco The School of Athensįor all Aristotle’s reputation as the greatest of the ancient philosophers, most today rightly bracket off his defence of slavery and his dim view of the intellectual capacities of women as unfortunate examples of how even the greatest minds are still products of their times.

Aristotle political philosophy